Ok so we all have our least favourite lines, vote for them!

[Ephel Duath]

Lets get a clear idea of just how much we can't stand those cheesy lines in the film. I know it'll make me a whole lot happier!:thumbs: roflmao

[Tar-Ancalimë]

DOWN WITH LIV TYLER I CANNOT STAND THAT LINE

OOOOOOOHHHHHHHH DEATH TO HER

AND THAT IS HER WORST LINEverymadverymadverymad

[Ephel Duath]

woah Tar! glad u think so, it kills me!! nobody cries after knowin sum1 4 a few hours!She's pathetic!Sum1 shoot her!:archer::batty::dragon:

[Akiba]

how can anyone thonk that sam line is lame nooooo it's so good but anyways of course I hated "you shall be the.." blah blah blah

[Tary]

I like arwen but this is the worst line in the whole movie ARWEN-"Don't give in frodo!Not now STUUUUUUUUPPPPPPPPIIIIDDDDDD!!!!!!!!!

[Nessa]

I voted Arwen. ;) She had a line I personally thought was even worse of a clinker, but that one's a close second.

(You'd all better be glad no one has voted for the adorable Sam line, the evil in me tends to come out when hobbits are bashed.... :evilcool: )

[A! Elbereth]

Originally posted by Tar-Ancalimë
DOWN WITH LIV TYLER I CANNOT STAND THAT LINE

OOOOOOOHHHHHHHH DEATH TO HER

AND THAT IS HER WORST LINEverymadverymadverymad

I voted on Arwen too... but I do not wish death on anyone lol ;)

personally I though Sams line was awesome and even though Frodo's was obvious, I liked all of his lines... I think....

[Lady Ashley]

I voted Arwen...though I do think Elrond's line was really cheesy too. Oh, and maybe Aragorn's "Let's hunt some Orc" line, which is slightly less cheesy, but still is. Good grief. Note that two cheesy lines are by a couple elves...and all by PJ. Coincidence? I think not. Ya know, I want to re-vote and go with Elrond's, but alas, I cannot.

Tolkien had no cheesy lines. Only good ones!!!

[Miruvor]

Why did you put Sam's line in there. That is a Tolkien line, only very slightly changed - see page 126. :(
Should only bash PJ's lines, yes yes.
:trout:

[Bonos-Girl]

i was torn between arwen and frodo...but arwen lost in the end.....couldn't give in to the temptation!!

[Ephel Duath]

nessa?which line of arwens did u hate the most?
sorry to u lot who complained about me puttin sams line in there.....thinkin about it its not that cheesy just really sweet.
i guess i was stuck for cheesiness and i needed to fill up 4 choices.Mental Block!!!!lollollollol

[TheRingBearer]

IMO the winner of the cheeiest line goes to *drum roll*

ELROND

(Arwens line may seem to not make much sense but she obviously knows why how much the ringbearer has gone through, hence the 'not now' part)

[Ephel Duath]

ok ive decided ur all right. I'm gonna change the poll cos i just thought of this and the cheesiness blew up in my face

ARWEN-"Whats this? A ranger caught off his guard?"

Better people? Down with arwens cheesiness!!:gofatty:

[Ephel Duath]

oh yeah i cant do that can i?durrrrrrrrrrr............:huh:im not aloud!:nono:

[Belaqua]

Elronds line got my vote, although Arwen cannot be forgiven for her ridiculous hormonal display

[Ephel Duath]

Arwen cannot be forgiven for her ridiculous hormonal display

Always so technical Bel. I believe wot Arwen does is being lame, not hormonal.Wow i hope no 1 in here likes arwen, sorry if they do! Dont hurt us! :blush::angel:

[Nessa]

Originally posted by Ephel Duath

ARWEN-"Whats this? A ranger caught off his guard?"


:grin: In an earlier post you asked which line of Arwen's I hated the most. And then you went ahead and got it by yourself! roflmao

[Little Devil]

I think the ranger line's funny, Aragon's face. lol

[Tar-Ancalimë]

Me too! :thumbs: it's great, he's all, "oh great, I don't have time for this, someones attacking me and I've got a seriously sick ringbearer over here, how could i be so stupid as to let this happen"!!!!
lol it makes me laugh tho i agree it is something arwen never would have said

still i hate this one line of hers waaaay worse arg that breathy senseless meaningless voice going oooooooh froodo!!! oh no! let my grace pass to him!!!!!!!!! spare him because i say so!!!!!

sorry :grin: im done ranting now

[Polly Sandybanks]

I voted Arwen. I really don't like that line.. I don't know why they even put that in the movie..

[Undomiel]

Originally posted by Tar-Ancalimë
Me too! :thumbs: it's great, he's all, "oh great, I don't have time for this, someones attacking me and I've got a seriously sick ringbearer over here, how could i be so stupid as to let this happen"!!!!


OMG yes! that's exactly it! lol lol roflmao
I didnt like the Frodo, Elrond or Arwen lines (the Sam one is soooo cute) but.....

i voted Elrond. It really is a bad line-only just saved by the dear pippin. I mean at least in the book he calls them the Company.

[Nessa the Dancer]

I had to do eeny meeny miny mo between Elrond and Arwen. Arwen won, but I still think that Elrond's line is terrible.

[Bonos-Girl]

i didn't mind it that much *gasps of horror* it didn't really annoy me at all. it was the combination of the song and the line that was kinda cheesy and that was the only reason the line was so bad...thats my theory anyway!

[Ephel Duath]

i agree that pippin saves elronds line. and also about aragorns face wen arwen gets him, looks like he's having muscle spasms in his neck lol

[Galadriel]

I think that Elrond line is pretty cheesy along with Arwen's too.

[Little Devil]

Originally posted by Ephel Duath
i agree that pippin saves elronds line. and also about aragorns face wen arwen gets him, looks like he's having muscle spasms in his neck lol

Spasms!!! roflmao roflmao damn true though!

[Dawnnamira Nerwen]

I think all of the choices are cheesy. But, Arwen's won out. I never really liked any of her lines. Something about the fact that Glorfindel wasn't there always made me hate her. :p

[Undomiel]

ah Glorfindel how i miss him.

[Ephel Duath]

maybe pj just couldnt find sum1 great enough to play glorfindel...
im glad sum1 finally thinks all the lines r cheesy!!lol
arwen wins again!!lol

[Catz]

heheheh was there ever any doubt she would??lol lol lol
:catz:

[Lennon]

I voted Arwen. Not that the line is so stupid- I just think the others are not cheesy at all.

[Lennon]

We all miss Glorfindel :(

[Undomiel]

yeah-there should be an army for glorfindel

[Little Devil]

Good Idea. :knight:

[Bonos-Girl]

there are already way too many armys guys!! half of them don't even need an army!!

[Eowyn]

argh! arwen's stupid line! :archer:

[Tar-Ancalimë]

yeah... but see... my take on this is, armies are for defending guys against bashers... come on now, who bashes Glofindel? Or even some of the others, for that matter....

But I digress... ignore me :grin:

Anyway... least favorite line.... yeah Arwen. Hate that line. :angry: why does it have to be so irritating?

[Undomiel]

i dont think ne1 really bashed Orli until Orli's army was set up lol

[Bonos-Girl]

some people bashed leggy though and orli's army has more of a ring to it!!! some people bashed him a couple of months back i think....

[Tar-Ancalimë]

anti leggy army came first guys!

[Bonos-Girl]

did it?? i thought orlis army came first *runs off to check* nope..i was right...orli's army started a day before the anti-lego army!!

[Tar-Ancalimë]

heh... my mistake... actually. my time, they were created the same day... but you're right, the Orli's Army was a few hours before... ok so my memory stinks lol

[Catz]

lines guys, lines lollol
it looks like theres pretty much a concensus of opinion here.....Arwens line sux lol
:catz:

[Tar-Ancalimë]

oh yeah, huh... somehow i thought this thread was about orli... weird...

lol im only kidding catz... yeah I think that line of Arwen's is my least favorite of all the lines in the movie... next would have to be "And I suppose you think you're the one to do! Never trust an elf!" However, on the plus side, Legolas's look after that line is priceless... :loveyou:

lol... look at me... you drag me back on topic and I still find a way to talk about Orli!! I need a life... :rolleyes:

[Eowyn]

therefore orli's army ws inevitable!

[Mirkgirl]

whoa a thread where I can vote against Arwen and I haven't posted here yet?!?! heheh C'mon she's not supossed speak until the wedding ( :trout: but there is a good reason - see what happens when she gets lines :trout: ) All she is allowed to do is stare at Frodo!

[Catz]

mirky....im disappointed in you.......and to think i usually follow you around to find them:rolleyes: lol lol
:catz:

[Mirkgirl]

roflmao roflmao roflmao I know :blush: lol roflmao

[Isiltári]

That Arwen line is so cheesy, lol.

[Eowyn]

yes I think almost everyone is agreed on that. I bet she says something in TTT which makes us cringe, just you wait.... she will! I'm sure she does it on purpose. :huh:

[Belaqua]

Of course she will. Its obvious. Why they can't script any decebt stuff for her is beyond me. Its seemed like every line she spoke in FOTR was cheesy or cliched. Or maybe that was just Liv Tyler. I'm just so predujiced against her now that its hard to tell what really annoys me about her. Oh well, back to burning Arwen effigies.

[Tar-Ancalimë]

I agree with you Eowyn!! She probably will... its inevitable... and she just wants to make us all furious, I guess... I mean, her only redeeming quality is her looks lol and that's not saying much!

you know, B, the rest of the movie lines are good... I bet it's just Tyler ;)

[Eowyn]

probably ;)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

oh lordy look at that... the first and third options got a vote... I see whoever voted for them wasn't brave enough to come out and admit it! :battle:

[Eowyn]

yes let them show themselves! :archer:

[Little Devil]

Come out come out wherever you are. :p (we wont hurt you,promise ;) )

[Firith Evenstar]

easy on the arwen evilness! she cried cause she's an elf! she knows man! lol

"i don't mean to..." heh. poor sam he's so simple. :)

[Firith Evenstar]

but i like him...not that i don't....some of you scare me sometimes..*gulp* :o :elfeek: :o

[Belaqua]

maybe Arwen knows Frodo a bit better than shes led us to believe....... *coughs*pervyhobbitfancier*coughs* Hey, 2 people have voted for the Sam line now. How could they neglect the cheesyness of elrond and arwen?

[Tar-Ancalimë]

Originally posted by Little Devil
(we wont hurt you,promise ;) ) ha! maybe she won't hurt you, but i wouldn't be too sure about the rest of us!!! THREE people now to get :battle: heh little scared are we??? im only kidding guys, you know that... i think.

[Bonos-Girl]

omg...people actually DIDN'T vote for arwens line....this calls for some serious action :battle:

[Little Devil]

Fun! :knight: :battle:

[Firith Evenstar]

heh, scared of you..rat! I laugh at this notion! *laughs* mwahaa

[Eowyn]

we shall have the last laugh! :archer: now everyone who didn't vote for arwens line speak now!

[Adunauriel]

I actually can't remember which one I voted for. I think it was Arwens.:mmmm:

[Akiba]

I actually voted for Elrond's line and I know I missed something.. why all the violence?

[Adunauriel]

I think it's because they think her's was the cornyest, but I'm not sure;)

[Eowyn]

yes 'hers' was the cheesiest! I cringe everytime I hear it!

[Bonos-Girl]

which for me is quite a lot of the time!!! i tried to skip that line on the dvd but it kinda disrupted the whole flm so now i leave it in....cheesy as it is!

[Adunauriel]

Suggestion B/G why don't you Mute your TV while watching that little bit. That way you don't hear her, but don't disrupt the flow of the film.:thumbs:

[Tar-Ancalimë]

Arwen's not worth the effort. Nor is she worth the effort it takes to diss her, or to fight those who don't diss her :rolleyes:

thus speaks the voice of reason........I cant believe that actually came from me lollol................

liv HAS RUINED arwen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! may she live a CURSED life hereforth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Adunauriel]

Tar, let me guess.... :mmmm: You don't like Liv? I don't blame you. Except for me it's cause she's in a Movie with the Beautiful Orlando....:drool: , for Orli........ Not Livpfbbt to Liv.

[Tar-Ancalimë]

bingo! you guessed perfectly. I hate her. No, that's not true. I don't HATE anyone, so to speak. I dislike the role she played in the movie FotR. yes... that is a better way of putting it :)

[Adunauriel]

I understand completely....:thumbs:

[Akiba]

ok I really dislike Liv with a passion but I like arwen don't know how that's possible but ti is

[Adunauriel]

I like Arwen also, but didn't necesasarily like Live in the Part. Some of it not all of it.

[Bonos-Girl]

well....arwen in the books cool...its just liv / taking glorfindels lines that ruined her in the film.

[Mirkgirl]

Originally posted by Tar-Ancalimë
Arwen's not worth the effort. Nor is she worth the effort it takes to diss her, or to fight those who don't diss her :rolleyes:

thus speaks the voice of reason........I cant believe that actually came from me lollol................

liv HAS RUINED arwen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! may she live a CURSED life hereforth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well many things don't worth the effort, but we still do them

Voice of reason... you? Stranger things have happened... maybe

I don't mind Liv as Liv, but she did ruin Arwen.. but I don't blame her.. it's the director who makes the movie, she just did her best (which was nothing in this role)

[Belaqua]

Poor Liv. Poor Arwen. Poor us. Poor Tolkein. I saw a trailer for TTT the other day, and Arwen has these scenes with Elrond. BUT SHE ISN'T EVEN IN TTT THE BOOK! ARRRGGGGHHHH! Poor me.

[Adunauriel]

yea, but we knew when they hired an actress like Liv, they were going to put her in the movie as much as possible. Even if she isn't the greatest of Actresses.

[Belaqua]

Alas, she is pretty, therefore she gets undeserved screen time. Shes winning in the poll too. I still think that Elrond deserves it, but thats just me.

[Adunauriel]

Yep that's what I ment, she's pretty. And I agree, Elrond is pretty bad too.:thumbs:

[Mirkgirl]

Yeah as I said before Tolkien didn't even mention Arwen throughout Books III and IV
I like Liv, but I hate her Arwen... no need to have more of her, she spoiled enough already hehehe
Elrond was bad... but he didn't take Gimli's place or something

[Adunauriel]

Nope he didn't.:thumbs: ( I ment Elronds Quote was bad, should have edited that post)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

Originally posted by Mirkgirl
but I don't blame her.. it's the director who makes the movie, she just did her best (which was nothing in this role) no not necessarily. PJ expanded the role because Liv asked for it, and she got what she wanted not because of her skill. don't blame PJ (yes that's an order ;))

[Mirkgirl]

oh come on, that's not the way things work

[Tar-Ancalimë]

not usually. but in this case, they did

[Adunauriel]

I agree with Tar. I think they gave her a bigger part to make her happy. But I do believe that PJ allowed it to happen.

[Tar-Ancalimë]

ofc he allowed it to happen... it's his movie... but he never would have done that much if he wasn't pressured.

[Belaqua]

Is there anybody here who is not filled with murderous rage whenever Arwen comes on screen? Or is that just me *goes and hides in a corner, silently cursing film Arwens name* Poor Glorfindel

[Adunauriel]

For me it's kinda :huh: I do I don't it all depends.

Any scene with Legolas, I Hate Her!!!!!!:flamer:

Other then that I don't mind her to much....

[Lady Ashley]

Blah...cheesy Arwen line...I hate her breathy voice. *ick* Liv in real life has a softer voice that sounds more like an elf voice than her Arwen-voice.

A friend put it this way..."Why is she so wimpy in real life?" (i.e. her 'bio' on the dvd. She doesn't even TALK about her ROLE, all she cares about is the CLOTHES. Sheesh, leave the clothes for another section. They're great and all (I love them!), but sheesh). But then again, riding around saving hobbits is NOT Arwen's personality. As in, BOOK personality. She sits at home and sews flags. No wonder she had nothing except clothes to talk about on the dvd! lol

Her breathy voice, and that stupid line, get on my nerves. *grrrr*

*calms down* Ok, enough Arwen-bashing for this thread.

My point: I hate her line. Elrond's too. Gee, the movie was great, why ruin it by cheesy lines?

[A! Elbereth]

Arwen is just floating there for me.... I don't really think she did bad or good

[Adunauriel]

True enough A! E, and basically that's how I feel. I think thou that maybe she just gets on my nerves a little too much. Other then that I'd probably say she did the best she could.:)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

Originally posted by Lady Ashley Thalionwen
My point: I hate her line. Elrond's too. Gee, the movie was great, why ruin it by cheesy lines? thank you!!! great minds, Ash, great minds ;)


I agree completely... and guys... if that was Liv's best... I'm afraid she shouldn't have been chosen to play that role. Because this best was not good enough, no, it wasn't even good at all. IMHO.

[Eowyn]

Originally posted by teddyjen25
Tar, let me guess.... :mmmm: You don't like Liv? I don't blame you. Except for me it's cause she's in a Movie with the Beautiful Orlando....:drool: , for Orli........ Not Livpfbbt to Liv.

oh dear have you heard about his new film 'calcium kid' ? erm........ I won't mention his co-star but you're not going to like it!
*ducks out of range*

[Tar-Ancalimë]

oh yeah... that is just about the worst news ever... don't you just hate her?

[Adunauriel]

Ok, So who's his co-star in Calcium Kid? Don't shoot me for asking..... Please:)

[A! Elbereth]

Clacium Kid? Sounds like a cartoon for 5 year olds...lol probably is... no offense

[Eowyn]

erm.......pkay
billie piper
as in the one married to chris evans:(

its about boxing A! E some boxer although orli boxing I think.....hmmm......

[Little Devil]

Interesting! :p So billie piper is his co-star?

[Eowyn]

rather worrying! :p she can't sing but can she act?

[Adunauriel]

ok, Billie Piper. Hard for me to hate her cause I don't know who she is. I'll dislike her emencely thou cause she's in this movie with Orlando.:)

[Eowyn]

lol don't worry you didn't miss anything! lol

[Adunauriel]

Ok, I wont worry. I'll hate her anyways......lol

[Brindlescruff]

Arwen's, by far....

You just met him! Stop panicing!pfbbt

[Samwise Gamgee]

i voted the fellowship but i think there were worse lines in the film.

[Yar]

Sam's line..

[Tar-Ancalimë]

wow! someone admitted to hating that line :o (1 out of 5!)

hey :battle: sam's line is sooo cute :loveyou: it rocks!

[Firiel]

I agree with you, Samwise, there were worse lines in the film that Tolkien didn't write and would never have written. The shocker for me was spoken by Aragorn toward the end of the film. I don't remember the exact quote but something close to: "Let's go get some Ork". :elfeek:

Firiel

[Adunauriel]

"Let's go hunt some Orc," I love that line. Mostly cause there's this really cool shot of Leggy gettin angry right after.;)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

"Let us hunt some Orc"

and why did that shock you? i think it was in keeping with Tolkien's lines. He delievered it well, and if you didn't think that line was true to the book, it probably follows that you didn't think most of the movie was true to the book :huh: I'll just keep this at "I disagree." ;)

[Firiel]

Originally posted by Adunauriel
"Let's go hunt some Orc," I love that line. Mostly cause there's this really cool shot of Leggy gettin angry right after.;)

Many fans did love that line. And I have to admit that ilol after the surprise wore off.

Firiel

[Firiel]

In THE DEPARTURE OF BOROMIR, Gimli says, "Well, after them...Dwarves too can go swiftly, and they do not tire sooner than orcs. But it will be a long chase; they have a long start. "

"Yes," said Aragorn, "we need all the endurance of Dwarves. But come! With hope or without hope we will follow the trail of our enemies. And woe to them, if we prove the swifter! We will make such a chase as shall be accounted a marvel among the three kingdoms: Elves, Dwarves, and Men. Forth the three Hunters!"

These are Tolkien's words but I guess that translates to "Let's go hunt some Ork.." That is why it was so funny to me. I don't recall Aragorn saying that but if you could quote the passage from the book, I will most humbly beg your forgiveness and agree that it is in keeping with Tolkien's lines.

I loved the film, Tar. Some of it was true to the book. Some of it wasn't. For those of us who have read it countless times, we enjoy comparing the two.:read:

Firiel

[Tar-Ancalimë]

lol i didn't mean that. no its not in the book, i agree... and ofc i understand that a lot of people enjoy comparing the two :grin:

well i loved it as well ;) and not everything is true to Tolkien... and some of the discrepancies bug me... but not too many lol

heehee about that line, I thought it was wonderful. then again that's just me :grin: and everyone knows im a little crazy sometimes ;) lol

[Undomiel]

i'm sorry i just couldnt take that line seriously. It reminded me of another movie (though i cant remember what it was now). It made me think more of ...o i dnt know..Bruce Willis or someone than Aragorn. That is just me though, i know loadsa ppl loved the line, so i'm not gnna argue :) I think the extended version is gonna be the best coz more of the things i missed will be in there and i wont mind the other things as much then.

[Firiel]

Originally posted by Tar-Ancalimë
lol i didn't mean that. no its not in the book, i agree... and ofc i understand that a lot of people enjoy comparing the two :grin:

well i loved it as well ;) and not everything is true to Tolkien... and some of the discrepancies bug me... but not too many lol

heehee about that line, I thought it was wonderful. then again that's just me :grin: and everyone knows im a little crazy sometimes ;) lol

Hi Tar: I'd love to know what discrepancies bugged you. For me the biggest one was the presence of Arwen where she should not have been. So of course in the poll I voted for Arwen having the cheeziest line because she never said it. I don't think she speaks at all in Rivendell, does she? :shhh:

Firiel

[Firiel]

Originally posted by Undomiel
i'm sorry i just couldnt take that line seriously. It reminded me of another movie (though i cant remember what it was now). It made me think more of ...o i dnt know..Bruce Willis or someone than Aragorn. That is just me though, i know loadsa ppl loved the line, so i'm not gnna argue :) I think the extended version is gonna be the best coz more of the things i missed will be in there and i wont mind the other things as much then.

Undomiel, That's exactly how I felt when I first saw the film. Bruce Willis! lol That's a good one. But when I saw it again I had to laugh, don't know why, I think the first time I took the film too seriously and was so disappointed, but on seeing it the second time I relaxed more and enjoyed it for what it was and didn't moan mecry so much.

Firiel

[elfgirl]

I kinda liked both of Arwen's lines. (becomes really tiny and timid) But the one line that HAS to go? I can't think of one! I love them all! (now THAT was cheesy)

[Bonos-Girl]

yes that was extremely cheesy!!!

[Adunauriel]

Don't worry elfgirl. Even thou I agree with B/G that was some Extreem Cheese. It's welcome here, and so are you....:thumbs:

[Wilwarin]

Hi guys! I just found this thread (I don't come into this forum very often). It looks like most everyone hates the Arwen line.........hmmm.........I don't like it much myself, but I had to vote for the Elrond one, simply because it makes me laugh out loud every time I watch the movie! lol Especially with the music building right then! I used to think that maybe it would sound better without music. But then he says it on the behind the scenes without music and it's even funnier!

Oh, and shame on anyone who voted for the Sam quote! :nono: I thought that was the cutest line! Especially when he says it at the end. It made me cry! mecry

[Wilwarin]

Oh, by the way. I just thought I would mention that the Frodo quote goes "Shire....Baggins? But that would lead them here!"

You said Baggins.....Shire. Anyway......... : D

[Undomiel]

yeah. i think it's difiicult for any actor to carry off saying a line that has already been said straight before. It just doesnt ever work. (i noticed this the other day in HP)

[Little Devil]

Really? Where? :huh:

[Adamanta Baggins]

aww, 4 of u guys think sam's line is cheesy? lol i thought it was adorable.

definetely liv's line...... not that it's "such a terrible line", i just can't stand her so, there ya go.:)

-Adamanta

[Aranel Eruntale]

Oops. I accidently voted for Sam's line when it's one of my favorites. It's so sweet.

I guess my least favorite line would have to be either Arwen's or Elrond's because I also love Frodo's line.

[Elanor]

Sam's line isn't cheesy--it's important to the story! It shows just how dedicated he is to Frodo and his intent to keep the promise he made (to the elves in the book, to Gandalf in the movie).

What about the dwarf tossing lines? Hasn't anyone thought those were the least bit cheesy????

[Daughter of Gondor]

When Legolas says "An heir to the throne of Gondor" its like duh, doen't everybpdy know that by now
Waist of time.

[Ariel]

Voted with the majority here....had to be Liv's line it was totally lame !!!!!!!!

Ariel

(thought Sam's line was cute......)

[Adunauriel]

I also think Sams line is cute... One of my fave lines actually...:thumbs:

[Daughter of Gondor]

Maybe if he didn't repeat "I don't mean to"

But he was sopping wet and it was convincing. You just can't critisize Sam.

[P.K. Brandybuck]

Originally posted by TheBow
When Legolas says "An heir to the throne of Gondor" its like duh, doen't everybpdy know that by now
Waist of time.

Baromir didn't know.
:)

[Filthylittlethief]

My vote for Elrond also. I alomost assumed he would be able to count to 9, living for 2 ages od Middle-earth now!
But I am quite perplex why you put in Sam's line?????? I LOVE THAT LINE!! It's my very favorite, it makes me cry everytime because he is so honest and simple when he says that!

[SindarinGirl]

Originally posted by Elanor
Sam's line isn't cheesy--it's important to the story! It shows just how dedicated he is to Frodo and his intent to keep the promise he made (to the elves in the book, to Gandalf in the movie).

What about the dwarf tossing lines? Hasn't anyone thought those were the least bit cheesy????

Agreed - Sam has to explain to the audience that he's sticking by Frodo, since the scene where he actually promised was cut out. It's an important line. :thumbs:

Yeah, the dwarf tossing reference made me groan. pfbbt

Totally MHO

[Friday's Dust]

Elrond's line was so cheesy it sounded cool. lol

And I agree, Sam's line wasn't cheesy at all. It really moved me and showed me how much dedicated and loyal he was to Frodo and we get a sense of strong friendship that will build as the story progresses.

I did however cringe at Arwen's lines. :mmmm:

[Daughter of Gondor]

Originally posted by P.K. Brandybuck
Baromir didn't know.
:)

Boromir knew. The line before it was "A-Aragorn... this is Isidur's heir." Hoho, Boromir knew.

It was basically for the non-book people who didn't know. Also to add some drama, and of course lines for the Lego-lovers.

[SindarinGirl]

Originally posted by TheBow
Boromir knew. The line before it was "A-Aragorn... this is Isidur's heir." Hoho, Boromir knew.

It was basically for the non-book people who didn't know. Also to add some drama, and of course lines for the Lego-lovers.

I think Boromir knew that a man named Aragorn was Isildur's heir, he just didn't know that the man sitting in front of him was Aragorn.
Yeah, it was a total intro for the audience. And we'll take just about all the Legolas lines we can get our sweaty little palms on, thank you. ;)

Totally MHO

[Bonos-Girl]

it was kinda stoopid though cos they obviously woul;dn't be sitting there talking about saving the world without having a clue who everyone was!! lol

[SindarinGirl]

Maybe Elrond was a bad host and didn't introduce everyone.
Maybe he could have made sure everyone had nametags.

"Hello, My Name Is: Gimli
And I Am A: Dwarf"

lol

All he said by way of introduction was that they were all there representing their races and to discuss the fate of this Ring.

[P.K. Brandybuck]

Originally posted by TheBow
Boromir knew. The line before it was "A-Aragorn... this is Isidur's heir." Hoho, Boromir knew.

It was basically for the non-book people who didn't know. Also to add some drama, and of course lines for the Lego-lovers.

Nawwwwwwww... I only meant that he wasn't told that this person was Aragorn....he knew of Aragorn but didn't know that
Viggo's character was Aragorn.

:rolleyes:;)

[P.K. Brandybuck]

Originally posted by SindarinGirl
Maybe Elrond was a bad host and didn't introduce everyone.
Maybe he could have made sure everyone had nametags.

"Hello, My Name Is: Gimli
And I Am A: Dwarf"

lol

All he said by way of introduction was that they were all there representing their races and to discuss the fate of this Ring.

That would be funny!

[Pippin Holbytlan]

I had to vote for Sam...I really don't like that line...*rolls eyes*

[Beleriel]

Well it just HAD to be that bargain basement quote... from Arwen... sounds like shes offering Frodo as an add on feature!

Ive always hated it!

[SindarinGirl]

How do you really feel Beleriel? Don't hold back. lol
(and welcome, too) :thumbs:

[Beleriel]

Oooh thank you!

erm... Im not very good at holding back! Sorry!

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Originally posted by Friday's Dust
Elrond's line was so cheesy it sounded cool. lol
I did however cringe at Arwen's lines. :mmmm:

Totally agree:hooray:

[Gwaihir]

I really wanted to vote for both Elrond's and Arwen's line. They are both soooo cheesy! pfbbt Arwen's "Frodo! No!" scene was so weird. She was in such a hurry to save him until she passed the river! lol Oh, and by the way welcome, Beleriel! :wave:

[Beleg Strongbow]

Even though I voted for Arwen's line, I still think that she's the cuddliest Elf...

[Roxanne Elessar]

I don't like any of those lines, it's Aragorn:loveyou: lines that I LOVE!!!!!! ARAGORN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :loveyou::loveyou::loveyou: :loveyou::loveyou::loveyou:
:loveyou::loveyou::loveyou:

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Well, but this poll is for the cheesiest lines. Obviously you wouldn't find Aragorn's speeches in here lol

[Eámanë Greenleaf]

OMG... Arwen's line there is SO corny... I mean, she just met Frodo, you don't get all teary-eyed over someone you just met.

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Yes, it totally made me cringe when she was hugging him and calling out his name... yerch! *goosebumps*

[Luvara]

I voted for Elrond, but I wanted to vote for Arwen too! I think they are just so...pfbbt

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Well, Elrond's line was pretty corny. lol

[Luvara]

yeah!:p

[YayBoromir!]

I voted Arwen, although Elrond was a close second. I don't think Frodo's line is that corny... :)

YB!:cool:

[Luvara]

no, and I really don't think that Sam's line was corny!!!

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Yar, Frodo's and Sam's lines aren't that corny.

[YayBoromir!]

No, they're not. I always think Elrond's line seems even more corny when you hear him say it on one of the features on the DVD (the one which allows you to see how scenes were pieced together) roflmao

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

the council of elrond editorial right? I don't know if it's just me but I thought that when he was doing certain takes, he seemed to say that line slightly faster than the norm.

[YayBoromir!]

Yeah, I thought that too. A lot of the lines sounded different - probably because of the ADR or the music playing over the top. It sounded strange to hear him say it quickly!

[Luvara]

well, I didn't like it at all... pfbbt

[Daeron]

Love the vote - most amusing debate thus far also :-)

I have to say I voted for Frodo's line. I agree with what people have said about Arwen's line - it's very cheesy. But Frodo's apparent blinding flash of realisation is so bone-headed.

'But...that will lead them *here*!'

Gee, ya think so!? By Eru's codpeice Mr Baggins, I'm glad you mentioned it because I sure as hell couldn't see it that one marching over the horizon under a vast pall of dust, beating drums and setting a crown of fire upon the horizon.

:->

[Ludibunda]

I guess I'm a sap, because those "cheesy lines " are some of my favorites!

Arwen's seem faithless - like she has no clue of Frodo's strength

[P.K. Brandybuck]

See I understand Arwen's line this way: She just finished busting her hump trying to save Frodo and she knew that his safety was important to Aragorn and she probably felt frustration and sadness as he was a hobbit and elves look upon hobbits like innocent and small creatures that need protection.
She was probably also upset that she was going to fail Bilbo also.
well...that's just my take on it, anyway.

I actually like Sam's line - I voted for Elrond's line.

[Luvara]

hmm... maybe your right! I like the way you think! ;)
And I lilke Sam's line too! :thumbs:

[Lasgalen]

I didn't vote because my least favorite line is when the nazgul calls Arwen she-elf. I somehow can't imagine professor Tolkien ever using that term.

-Lasgalen

[P.K. Brandybuck]

Thanks love_Aragorn!!!!

Well actually I got teary during Arwen's scene the first time I saw FOTR and I had to justify it somehow!!!!!! :)