Just for the Guys... Who's the Coolest Girl?

[Aldalaire]

I noticed that there aren't any polls for you guys to say who the hottest girl is. So, I figured I'd do one. (And in case you girls want to say something, you can say who's the coolest, not the hottest.)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

I'm no guy, But Eowyn is my favorite. For the reasons that Otto did a fantastic job, that Liv did a terrible job (as a contrast), that I don't know enough of Rosie to say, and that both Tom and Goldberry got to me, I didn't like them much, too odd

and wheres Galadriel? She's a very important female character and doesnt deserve to get lumped with 'other'

[Illuvatar]

Goldberry rocks!

Something about them there nature babes! :p

[Sindarin]

Eowyn is the coolest girl, :cool: and by far the hottest. :naughty:

I love Eowyn! :loveyou: :p

[Saruman]

I think that Eowyn is the best.
I regard Goldberry and Bombadil as hippies. Goldberry would be a close second.

[Aldalaire]

Sorry about Galadriel, Tar. Was in a hurry when I created the poll and I couldn't think at the time.

[Tar-Ancalimë]

lol, tis all right

[Lasgalen]

Once again I have to choose "other". I can't believe Galadriel keeps getting left out. She is definitely the hottest.

As for coolest, I vote Goldberry. She is cool, man.

-Lasgalen

[Winyaél Greenleaf]

Haha, I'm not a guy, but I'm here to vote anyway. Ok, I've read that you left out Galadriel in a hurry, so I won't say anything else. I'll just vote 'Others'. :)
And I must say that I don't like Arwen.

[DudeOfGondor]

Eowyn she is most irresistable babe in middle earth
and probably the most deadliest since i don't know that Arwen can fight or not

faramir is sooo lucky.

[Fatty]

Other, Galadriel.............older woman, smart , athletic, fancy penthouse gardens, mind you there is pesky Celeborn.

[Lasgalen]

Celeborn seems kinda slow. Easy to get around. It's me you have to worry about. lol

-Lasgalen

[Eowyn]

Aldalaire who's your favourite? you strated the thread but didn't give your opinion.

anyway I haven't voted 'cos you seem to want just males opinions. but I thin you know who I'd vote for lol

[Galadriel]

Well I would have voted for other considering Galadriel is not listed. I thought she was the coolest. She was wise and fair. Of course Eowyn would have been a very close second

[Lasgalen]

I totally agree with you. Galadriel first, with Eowyn a close second. :)

[Ireth]

Yes me too!
Oh and I am a girl by the way!
But honestly...I think Arwen is far more prettier...even prettier than Galadriel. Except that she is young and Galadriel is older and wiser. Eowyn,I think, Is no where close to being as attractive as the other two! But she can defend herself so thats a plus!
But thats just a girls opinion so I am not sure if it really matterslol

[Aldalaire]

Originally posted by Eowyn
Aldalaire who's your favourite? you strated the thread but didn't give your opinion.

anyway I haven't voted 'cos you seem to want just males opinions. but I thin you know who I'd vote for lol

I don't really have a favorite. I guess Eowyn was my favorite character, because she seemed like she was a little more independent.
Again, I wasn't think when I posted the thread, so I didn't put who the coolest/hottest. So you can vote if you want.

[Tirithel]

Originally posted by Saruman
I regard Goldberry and Bombadil as hippies.

and

Originally posted by Illuvatar
Just something about those nature babes!

I'm a chick, but definitely Goldberry- something about that psycho-delic (pun intended) green dress stuf and lilies around her feet...that's what I wanna do when I grow up!

[Tar-Ancalimë]

I really like the name Goldberry... does that count? lol

[Númenórean]

I voted Eowyn, becouse she just rocks. Sweet and nice most of the time but full of surprises lol

[Lasgalen]

Eowyn is my number two choice. Galadriel is still number one in my book.

[Tirithel]

Number two for me would have to be Rosie- she's too cute with those pudgy little hobbit cheeks- you just wanna SQUEEZE 'EM! lol

[Ireth]

Rosie? Ugh!
She looks like......there isnt even a description! Hobbit women are ugly i think...but thats just me....

[Tirithel]

Well hey if you can get past the big hairy feet and the bad perms...lol

[Lasgalen]

I did not find Rosie attractive, but I would not go so far as to say she was ugly.

[Tirithel]

Come on! Show some love! She was so totally a cutie!

Okay ,if ya won't agree with me, answer me this: She and Sam are perfect for eachother, are they not? Yah, come on, you know they are! :grin:

[Lasgalen]

Yes, they are perfect for each other. They make a great couple.

[Númenórean]

They make a great couple. They're just made for eachother.
I think Rosie is nice, but I'm not attracted to her at all. Give me Eowyn any minute lol

[Tirithel]

All right, I'm happy to have some agreement. :thumbs:
Anywho, back to the topic...

[Ireth]

Well I didnt mean the kind of ugly that got hit by a bus ugly...i meant not attractive...and yes if the perms were gone it would be much better!

[Tirithel]

HEY! I got hit by a bus- you callin' me ugly? lol

[Hobbit]

You did :elfeek: :o !
You gotta watch yourself Tirithel. Lucky you survived
as for the best girl: If you mean the bookversion I would go for Arwen but movieversion Eowyn.

[Tirithel]

Well, actually it was a '96 Cavalier, and I jumped outta the way so I just got clipped by the headlight- no serious damage, no worries. I just got a kick out of it when the doofus that did it was forced to write me an apology letter by his P.O. lol

Oh yeah, and no I'm NOT ugly- I happen to think I'm rather cute. lol

[Ireth]

No one in here is ugly...but the people out there are...*glances around nervously*
lolJ/k

[Kenzie]

i like movie and book version arwen... but bokk version better

[Ireth]

i like book version better also....

[Gil Galad]

teh hottest feamle is definitly Arwen, bu tthe coolest, id say Eowyn

[Lasgalen]

Arwen looks ok as long as she is not in profile. I prefer Galadriel. (From the books, I like Luthien)

[Ireth]

I strongly agree with both Gil and Las!

[Gil Galad]

no Arwen is much better lookin than Galadriel *has memories of something from LotR, where Faramir? and Gimli argue over who is teh fairest*

oh yeh Luthien wos by all accounts an absolut fox, as wos Idril, and Luthiens Daughter and .................................................. ....

[Tirithel]

Actually, as someone who does a lot of sketching, people with the ugliest profiles are the best looking head on. I mean, they have the most attractive faces, and vice-versa. CHeck out J-Lo's profile once- BLECH! What it is I think is the chin- chins that jut out are attractive from the front (as they tend to play down the potrusion of the nose) but kinda gaudy from the side, cuz they just seem to stick out. Check Arwen (I've never really looked). Am I right or what? Eager for answer. Yeah anywho I'll shut up now...

Oh yeah, I think it was Eomer that Gimli was arguing with...but again, I could be wrong...

[Gil Galad]

no i think ur rite, cos it started in tTT.

u mite be rite actually, but id still do her.

and J.Lo who cares about her Chin sthat woman has one fine ***

[Tirithel]

Hey hey now calm down man! (Er, elf...) I'll sick a mod on your post and get it edited! lol

[Ireth]

lolyeah do that....
Just playin gil....
Well if ihad to chose between being Arwen or Ewyon I would chose Ewyon because she has skills with a sword and she can actually take care of herself.....plus....her personality is much more like mine

[Gil Galad]

i apologise for any offense caused wit my post.<but i still ment every word>anyway, i think that Arwen, wud be much beter looking, her bening an elf and all, but the shield maiden of rohan is prety cool

[Altáriel]

I'm a girl,but i'm always defending Eowyn's character,so i voted for her,she's a hell of a woman:not only pretty(even for the elvish language),but brave,independent,wise,queenly,fearless....i want to be like her!!!!:p

[Ireth]

yeah.....me toolol

[Gil Galad]

but Arwens hot.......

[Hobbit]

Eowyn too...... even Aragorn was impressed by her.

[Gil Galad]

yeh but he went elf in the end

[Ireth]

well ofcoarse....us elves are the most beautiful creatures...except we just hate it when we brake a nail!lol

[Gil Galad]

its tough soemtimes being an Elf (the nail breaking doesnt bother me tho)

[Hobbit]

Hehe when you're batteling Sauron in many battles I don't think you'll be bothered much by a broken nail.......... but I think the Evenstar can afford to get her nail broken.

[Gil Galad]

yeh i think she'd still look very well

[Hobbit]

No doubt about that Gil lol
But since it's also about the coolest girl I go for Eowyn: Womans are more then meets the eye and she's is certainly a lot more then meets the eye.

[Gil Galad]

she is, and she aint hard on the eye either

[Hobbit]

I agree. Eowyn is one cool/pretty girl.
That's why I voted for her ;)

[Lasgalen]

My vote is for Galadriel. Although you are right about Eowyn, Hobbit.

[Ireth]

Well I think she is pretty for an older woman...but for the more younger generation (who can tell with elves?) arwen is at top...but for coolness...definetly Eowyn!

[Kenzie]

i'm still sticken with arwen ... though i know she wasn't in it much ... i really enjoyed her character

[Gil Galad]

is this just lord of the rings(im to lazy to check wot forum its in) but if its not, id say id go with Luthien, or Varda if thats allowed

[Tar-Ancalimë]

ofc it's allowed lol

tho i'm not positive varda is quite a 'girl' but hey... lol

[Gil Galad]

yeh i just thought of that, the Ainur just took on forms, so just cos they appear male/female it doesnt mean they r, i dont think that they really be described with gender.

anyway i say Luthien

[Hobbit]

Luthien woul be the prettiest of course, but I would prefer Idrill (the daughter of Turgon and the wife of Tuor)
She was supposed to be very, very pretty aswell... and she has a nice personality

[Lasgalen]

Luthien was the most beautiful Elf ever, but from the movie I like Galadriel.

[Gil Galad]

no id prefer Arwen from the movie:drool:

but luthien wasnt only prety, she whipped Morgoths ***, and her power was enough to put all the host of angband asleep

[Mánaskin]

im not a guy but i think Eowyn is the coolest......i mean she is great with a sword and thats cool:)

[Tar-Ancalimë]

erm... so why did you just say "im not a big fan of Eowyn" in the Eowyn thread? :huh:

[Mánaskin]

yeah but she is coolest of the female charaters im not a big fan tho

[Luthien Anwamanë]

Eowyn is the best!!!

[Ireth]

From the movie...Arwen...from the book....Luthien

[Arwen Evenstar]

I'm a gal so I'm just commenting on the coolest. Luthien is definitely coolest in the book, cuz she's extremely pretty and we can slash with a sword, but Eowyn is cooler in the film. I wish Arwen had more of part, especially in the book. All she did was stay in Rivendell and Lorien in the book. She had more of a part in the film, saving Frodo and all that (which was extremely cool!) but I wished she did more fighting!