PDA

View Full Version : Smith of Wootton Major


Ludibunda
May 17th,2003, 05:27 AM
I'm working on it - quite delightful! Anyone else ever partake?

Mirkgirl
May 17th,2003, 03:17 PM
Well I've read it... nice story, many hidden meanings as in all the Tolkien short stories... what do you have in mind?

Ludibunda
May 17th,2003, 03:57 PM
I think what I had in mind was to accomplish a Tolkien reading. I love happy Hobbit stories and faeries and trolls amd magicl But I never finish a book during the academic year because I'm so friggin' busy - SWM is so short and so sweet, I figured it is one thing I can accomplish - three nights of attempted reading and I'm only on page 24 of 63. (but with 6 picture pages - so I'm half way. Is that not sad? But I find it very encouraging and I tackle Unfinished Taled next - having already been befuddled by the first three sentences.
I DO LOVE hidden meanings, though rarely see them without a little assistance. Give me the weekend, Mirkmouse, then let's analyze, pretty please!!! Yippee! Thanks for noticing my post!

Mirkgirl
May 17th,2003, 04:33 PM
Sounds nice... I should refresh it as well... and find my copy which would probably take longer hehe I'm sure more people would like to join (:

Ludibunda
May 17th,2003, 05:46 PM
Ooo-Ooo intellectualism? - let's keep it low-level. I still got laundry, dishes, lesson plans and hubby to satisfy. Maybe just you and me and whoever stumbles on, ok?

Sindarin
May 19th,2003, 11:59 PM
I read this book quite a few times. It is a pleasant story and very enjoyable. :thumbs:

Ludibunda
May 20th,2003, 12:10 AM
I'm a little more than half way - it's extremely pastoral. I see hints of underlying social commentary, but it's not clear. Have you hear that certain events in the story represent event in Tolkien's time or that the trees, characters, star represent something special. I've always stunk an analysis but LOVE finding out the intended/hidden meanings.

Ludibunda
June 2nd,2003, 02:29 AM
OK! Done! Other than the nice story, what is Tolkien trying to say here? Anything deep?

Mirkgirl
June 5th,2003, 02:44 PM
I'm sorry but I've been awfully busy... I can't take part right now... Hopefully someone else has read this story and has something to say (: