PDA

View Full Version : Could the Druedain be the Wild Men?


Gwaihir
February 12th,2004, 12:47 PM
I'm still wondering whether I should post this in the LotR forum or in Tolkien's Other Works, because it's about both of them...

I was reading RotK today, just refreshing my memory before watching the movie, and read the part where the Rohirrim ride through Dunharrow. There they see the Pukel-men, ancient stone images of men.
Then when Theoden is talking to Ghan-buri-Ghan of the Woses, a breed of Wild Men who live in Druedan Forest, Merry sees similarity between the Woses and Pukel-Men.

This reminded me of a chapter in the Unfinished Tales: "the Druedain". The Druedain were short, squat, and wild kind of men who lived in the first age and hated orcs. They made sitting stone figures that they called watch-stones.

I think that Tolkien used the concept of Druedain for the Woses of LotR? Even the forest in which the Woses live sounds like "Druedain"! What do you think?

Glorfindel
February 12th,2004, 06:02 PM
They are indeed one and the same people. Druedain, Wild Men, Púkel-Men, Woses, ...
The stones in Dunharrow are some of the watch-stones.

Erendiel
February 18th,2004, 07:24 PM
In the book Unfinished Tales there is a whole chapter on them. It is very interesting.