What if...

[Ringwraith]

What if Tolkien had writen another book. Would you rather have it as a book completely dedicated to Arargorn and his adventures, or a book completely dedicated to Gandalf and his adventures?

[Polly Sandybanks]

I think I'd prefer one for each person of the fellowship, and possibly some other important people. Like the secret diaries. :)

[Bawax]

i'd like to read the complete tales of Treebeard or the ents in general. :)

[A! Elbereth]

It would be nice if there were actual, serious diaries for each character, being much longer of course. Sometimes I don't understand what a few of the fellowship are thinking in LOTR, unless I take a guess at it.

[Goldilocks]

Sindarin, I think Aragorn. His life was just so complex. And it'd be interesting to read about when he and Gandalf first met.

[Pil]

Gandalf's one would be VERY hard to do...extensive...

I reckon aragorn's would be more interesting anyway...any takers on the idea? :read:

[Mirkgirl]

The best about Gandalf is that he never tells everything.... So it'll be either dull or controversial book. So Aragorn

[Orc]

A complete history of Orcs

[Pil]

lol I know who'll be compiling THAT one!

[Calenhendi]

Something about the Stewards of Gondor or Eowyn would be nice.

[Pil]

I always wanted to know more about boromir's fights against mordor prior to the fotr thing... :huh:

[Galadriel]

If Tolkien was to write another book I think that it would be hard to pick just one person to write about. I would like to know more about Aragorn and Legolas and Gimli and Gandalf. Or how about tthe hobbits and stuff. i just think that it would be too ahrd to pick just one person.